Borehole vs water tank: which is right for your home?

Updated 19 November 2026 · Independent guide by Home Water Backup

A water tank is the right choice for most homes that want to get through municipal outages: it costs far less, goes in within days and stores water you know is treated. A borehole makes sense when outages are long and frequent, when you use a lot of water, or when you want independence from the municipal supply, and you can afford the risk that drilling finds too little water or water of poor quality. A borehole still needs a tank.

The basic difference

  • A tank stores water. It fills from the municipal supply or the roof and gives it back when the taps are dry. When it is empty, it is empty.
  • A borehole is a source of water. It draws groundwater from under your property for as long as the aquifer and the pump hold out.

Cost

Published figures for a borehole:

  • Drilling a borehole for a homeR50 000 to R120 000Published by Daily Maverick (quoting environmental scientist Ayesha Laher), published February 2025 · we read it on 19 November 2026 ·source
  • Complete borehole systemR60 000 to R120 000Published by BusinessTech (quoting Borehole Repairs), published February 2025 · we read it on 19 November 2026 ·source

These are figures published by the companies and publications named, not our own prices or quotes. Check what each includes before comparing.

The Borehole Water Association does not publish a price, and explains why: “In some areas viable quantities of water can be obtained at 30m. In other areas a hole might have to be drilled to 150m+.”

Published figures for a tank system:

  • Backup tank system, basic to fully integratedR7 000 to R35 000Published by Kandua, undated national estimate headed 2025 · we read it on 19 November 2026 ·source
  • Worked example: 2500 L tank, 0.75 kW pump, connected to mainsR13 500 to R21 500Published by Kandua, undated estimate headed 2025 · we read it on 19 November 2026 ·source
  • Typical home system with UV steriliser and reverse-osmosis filterR25 000 to R35 000Published by AfriPumps, seller's estimate as at January 2026 · we read it on 19 November 2026 ·source

These are figures published by the companies and publications named, not our own prices or quotes. Check what each includes before comparing.

A borehole also has running costs: electricity for the pump, water testing, filtration and pump maintenance.

The risk with a borehole

The Borehole Water Association is direct about it: “the drilling contractor cannot guarantee that the borehole will intersect water and therefore the client does take a certain amount of risk, as the client will be responsible for the cost of the borehole, regardless of what the ultimate yield is.”

A tank has no such risk. You know what you are getting before you pay.

If you go ahead with a borehole, the association advises asking whether the installer can provide proper yield and drawdown tests, which are needed to choose the right pump.

Water quality

Municipal water in a tank has been treated. Borehole water has not, and its quality depends on the ground under your property.

  • An environmental scientist quoted by Daily Maverick advises testing the water “when the borehole is first drilled, and annually”.
  • JoJo advises testing borehole water first to identify contaminants, and again every six months or so.
  • The City of Cape Town states that groundwater “may not generally be used for drinking, cooking or body washing” under its by-law.

Budget for testing and, very likely, filtration if you plan to use borehole water indoors.

What the law requires

National. Under the National Water Act, taking water “for reasonable domestic use in a person’s household from any source” is permitted without a licence. In July 2026 the Department of Water and Sanitation confirmed, according to OUTA, that households using borehole water for reasonable domestic purposes are exempt from registration, while commercial, agricultural and industrial users must register. Selling borehole water needs a licence. Draft regulations in 2026 proposed that all boreholes be registered, so the position may change.

Municipal. These rules apply on top of the national ones:

  • Cape Town: apply at least 14 days before sinking a borehole or wellpoint, and register it afterwards. Use must be metered.
  • Johannesburg: a borehole consent application process has applied since 1 October 2025. The City warns that drilling without approval risks fines and having work stopped.
  • Durban (eThekwini): using water from a source other than the municipal system needs the municipality’s consent.
  • Pretoria (Tshwane): the Borehole Water Association notes that drilling in suburbs on dolomite bedrock is prohibited unless certified safe by a registered professional.

A tank filled from the municipal supply needs none of this, though connecting it to your plumbing has its own rules. See how to connect a JoJo tank to your house.

A borehole still needs a tank

JoJo’s FAQ explains: “Borehole pumps are made to start, pump water over a distance for a period of time, and then switch off. They are not designed for switching on and off constantly for short periods of time.” So the borehole pump fills a storage tank, and a pressure pump supplies the house from the tank. The choice is often between a tank alone and a tank plus a borehole.

Which should you choose?

Your situation Likely better fit
Outages of a few days, a few times a year Tank
Limited budget Tank
Small property or a townhouse Tank
Outages lasting weeks, or no reliable municipal supply Borehole with a tank
Large garden, pool or smallholding Borehole with a tank
Area on dolomite, or with known poor groundwater Tank

Start with a tank sized for your household using the calculator. If you later add a borehole, the tank and pump will be reused.

Common questions

Is a borehole better than a JoJo tank?

They do different jobs. A tank stores water you already have and carries you through an outage. A borehole is a new source of water, at many times the cost and with no guarantee of yield or quality. Most homes that need backup for outages are well served by a tank.

Do I need to register a borehole?

Nationally, the Department of Water and Sanitation confirmed in July 2026, as reported by OUTA, that households using borehole water for reasonable domestic purposes are exempt from registration. Municipal rules are separate: Cape Town and Johannesburg require an application, and eThekwini requires consent. Draft national regulations published in 2026 proposed registering all boreholes, so check the current position.

Can I drink borehole water?

Only if it has been tested and is safe. Borehole water quality varies from one property to the next. The City of Cape Town says groundwater may not generally be used for drinking, cooking or body washing. Have the water tested when the borehole is drilled and regularly afterwards.

Do I still need a tank if I have a borehole?

Usually, yes. JoJo explains that borehole pumps are not designed to switch on and off for short periods, so the borehole fills a tank and a pressure pump supplies the house from the tank.

Sources

  1. Daily Maverick, Thinking of drilling a borehole in Joburg? Here's what you need to know (28 February 2025)
  2. BusinessTech, Households forking out up to R120,000 for another basic need (15 February 2025)
  3. Borehole Water Association of Southern Africa, Layperson's guide to boreholes
  4. OUTA, DWS confirms most household borehole users do not need to register (22 July 2026)
  5. Department of Water and Sanitation, Water use authorisation
  6. City of Cape Town, Apply to sink a borehole or wellpoint
  7. City of Cape Town, Alternative water sources
  8. City of Johannesburg, Joburg unveils new borehole application process (27 August 2025)
  9. Open By-laws (Laws.Africa), eThekwini Municipality Water By-law, 2023
  10. JoJo, Frequently asked questions